The other day I was standing in a department store when I heard the unmistakable “aaah-ah, aaah-ahhh-ahhh” of “You’re All I’ve Got Tonight” coming over the speaker in the sky. It made me even giddier than I usually get when I hear The Cars out and about because that song is not one that plays often in my neck of the woods. I looked at the people around me like, “Right???” but of course, no one connected. (My sweet kiddo gave me a ‘thumbs up’ though. Haha!)
“You’re All I’ve Got Tonight” is the sixth track on The Cars’ (perfect) debut album, and definitely one of the rockin-est! It was, of course, written by Ric Ocasek and produced by Roy Thomas Baker. Not nearly as arcane as many of his lyrics, Ric described the meaning of the song in this way: “When things get too quiet, and you’re willing to put up with any company, or you’re not willing to accept the prospect of being alone, you might find yourself needing what you’ve got.” (EA News, May, 1978)
Before you read any further in this article I just want you to grab some headphones and listen to this. I know, I know… you’ve heard it a zillion times… but please, I urge you, just take a few minutes and close your eyes and soak this in.
Those drums absolutely make my adrenaline take flight. And then you hear the first fuzzy guitar riffs, paired with Ric’s voice slicing into the music with those wonderfully apathetic lyrics… Everything about this song is huge and dark and pulsing. Well, until Greg joins in with his bright, sparkly strobe of synth notes that take the edge off just in time. And the background vocals are stunning — ah, Roy Thomas Baker! You’re a genius!
From what I understand, the only time this track was officially sent out into the world on a 45 was as the B side to “All Mixed Up” — in the Netherlands! But no matter. Both rock and mainstream radio station deejays and listeners loved it then and still do today; it continues to receive more than its fair share of ‘spinnage.’ (Hmm, surely I didn’t just make that word up?)
Now let’s take a quick step back in time and trace the history of this bad boy. YAIGT was around before The Cars were “The Cars.” According to Toby Goldstein in her book Frozen Fire: The Story of The Cars, Cap’n Swing was playing it in Boston in 1976. Having heard the interesting metamorphoses of other CS-to-The-Cars songs, I sure wish I could hear the Cap’n tackle this tune!
I don’t have an audio from back that far but fortunately for us, an early Cars’ demo was included on Rhino’s 1999 deluxe edition of the debut album. It was laid down during The Cars’ first-ever recording session in April of 1977, at Northern Recording Studio in Maynard, MA. In the liner notes Greg says, “As with ‘Just What I Needed,’ this particular recording also received considerable airplay prior to the first album coming out.” In other words, IT was a hit before THEY were a hit.
You hear the subtle differences right off the bat: you have Dave and Elliot entering with straight sounds, no technological manipulations. Then there’s the heavy bass, the raw (and a little sparse) backing vocals; a different spin on the synth at times. Filling in toward the end you hear the unique vocal mutterings of Ric and those various “woo!” exclamations that clearly testify to the high energy of the band. As always with their early stuff, you just know they *knew* they were killing it. Take a listen:
(It’s funny… my internal stereo always plays the beginning of “Bye Bye Love” after that last “tonight!”)
YAIGT became a concert staple. “We do that [song] all the time. I like that song. It’s just about ending up with somebody you don’t necessarily care to be ending up with, but something’s better than nothing,” Ric explains on the 1979 SuperGroups in Concert series. Indeed, according to setlist.fm (grain of salt, I know), The Cars performed this song 65 times beginning in April of 1977; it is their fifth most-played title. More often than not, it was played as the last one of the regular set or as part of the encore.
As you may recall, the band closed the televised portion of their performance on Rock Goes to College with it, and they nailed it. I love how Ric takes advantage of the live show to get a little naughty with the lyrics… and of course, the added slo-mo effects as the credits roll add the mint to this sweet tea. Check it out:
According to 98.5 WNCX Radio, Elliot enjoyed it, too. “’You’re All I’ve Got Tonight’ was a favorite of mine, if for no other reason than it was my chance to stretch out live. I usually used the solo at the end as a launching point and would take off until the other guys in the band sort of looked at me like ‘Okay already, enough,’ and then I’d give them their cue that we would go back into the song. But that was a fun one for me to play, because I always got to stretch on it.”
This performance from 2011 is a perfect example of that ‘stretching.’ The whole song is so stunning I can hardly keep from standing up and cheering at the end. Elliot blazes through those guitar parts like a freight train — check him out at about 3:00, where he kicks off just over a minute and a half of pure six-string badassery. And the crowd just eats it up! I watch this again and again and I just can’t help but internally beg the stars to align so that The Cars will tour one more time.
A search on Youtube will turn up a whole variety of folks doing covers of this song, with equally diverse success. I do have a few favorites among those efforts.
The one I like best sounds the most different to my ears, and I confess I didn’t really care for it on the first listen. It’s by an artist named David Raymer. It’s a little softer; the vocals are more melodic and kind of jazzy; he’s got kind of an Edwyn Collins vibe going on. I gave it another chance, liked it, wanted to hear it again… and then I kept coming back to it. There’s just something so unique about it; can’t really put my finger on it. What do you think?
Probably the most notable remake of YAIGT was done by The Smashing Pumpkins. A long-time fan of The Cars, lead singer/songwriter Billy Corgan added his metallic sawblade vocals and alternative-punk distortion, and then monkeyed with elements of the arrangement enough to add a definite (but not unpleasant) twist to this classic. The Smashing Pumpkins released their version on their 1996 box set called The Aeroplane Flies High. I’m not a big SP fan, but I am a little addicted to this! Take a listen here (you have to do some jimmy-jog with the settings but it works, I promise):
This cover also shows up in a snippet of the film The Saint, a successful 1997 thriller starring Val Kilmer and Elisabeth Shue. It’s just a tiny blip, to be sure (which is probably why it didn’t warrant a spot on the official soundtrack), but there it is. And the movie itself isn’t too bad, either.
I know I’ve mentioned the 2005 tribute compilation Substitution Mass Confusion in other articles… YAIGT was one of the songs included on that CD. It was covered by an alternative pop/rock band out of Chicago called The Millions. I still don’t have my own copy of it (it’s on the way!), but I did find a partial performance of the track on Youtube. It’s pretty rocking:
Just a couple of months ago I came across this one. Now, I am a big believer in passing music down to the next generation, so it’s very gratifying when I come across young people devoting their time and talents to learning The Cars’ catalog. This talented girl (can’t tell how old she is but she looks like a teenager) does a stellar job with EE’s solo:
Then there’s this one — and she is YOUNG. Watching this little gal gave me an education on what all Benjamin does in this song. For me, a lot of the bass is masked by the heavy guitars and I have a hard time picking it out. So many nuances I had never caught before! And I’m curious… how long did this girl practice this thing??? (She does a video of the lead guitar, too.)
I’ll tell you, for a song that never showed up on the Billboard charts, this heavy number sure has made its mark…. so much so that it’s still being played, forty years later, in a department store in a little town in the woods of Podunk, Idaho. And THAT, my friends, is why The Cars are being inducted in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. 😉
7 thoughts on “You’re All I’ve Got Tonight”
The thing I really like about the 1977 demo version is that (to my ears, anyway) the tempo is a bit faster than the official release. It adds to the underlying tension & driving urgency of needing to be with someone, anyone, rather than being alone. The Rock Goes to College clip edges closer to the demo speed, as does the 2011 performance clip. Although I don’t have a link, I think the faster tempo must be particularly noticeable in the 1978 live Agora performance. The first time I listened to my copy of that concert, I was surprised how much I enjoyed that song (not one of my favorites); I just didn’t realize until reading your article & comparing the clips that there was a tempo difference. I had just assumed that I liked the Agora version of the song simply because it was part of such an exciting live album. (What I wouldn’t give to have seen an early Cars concert!!) Of the clips you’ve included above, I think The Millions actually comest closest to capturing the raw exhilaration of the Agora performance.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for that insight! I didn’t really zero in on the difference in tempo… I’m not always the most discerning when it comes to audio, but I try to be! There are many live versions of this song and I didn’t listen to all of them — I’ll definitely be getting my Agora album out tomorrow. It’s been awhile since I put that one on the turntable. I’m glad you reminded me! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like the song. David’s Drum sound is so different. Or it was different sounding at least to me in 1977. I never had really listened to the lyrics. Ric’s vocalization are hard for me to pick out or hear over the background music. I have less than 30% hearing in my left ear. Probably at 62 it is much worse. I was wearing a hearing aid in my right ear but it is so old and digital would be so much better. My aged computer seems to not bring out the audio as well as it used to so I am down to some I-pod earphones. I do like the demo in that regard because I can hear more of the lyrics than on the album. That demo is quite raw but I like it. I wonder if a vinyl pressing would deliver a clear hearing. I just passed off as a put-down song by Ric. I think he was the best at that and being somewhat humorous in his writings. Imho would of the better lyricist of the new wave/post punk genre.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sorry about your hearing, my friend! I agree with you about Ric’s lyrics — he definitely had a sense of humor with an edge to it.
Awesomeness of The Cars always blows me away! And the 11 yr. old girl does an amazing job….keep up the great work girl!!!! Take it from a bassist of over 35 yrs. now, never stop playing n learning bass licks!!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was just driving in my car listening to Night Thoughts Episode Pop with you guys and Ken. WHAT!!!!!!
In Atlanta, you are in your car – a lot! I couldn’t wait to get back to my computer. Listening to Ken explain things that are in his wheel house mixed with you guys – wow. My head is still pounding after listening to him talk about YAIGT. Yes, yes, yes, I screamed when he pointed out how “it seems to pick up tempo as it goes along, it actually doesn’t change that much. What changes is the ferocity of the playing. It builds like a monster. You become disoriented in the song”. This is exactly what I feel when I hear it.
We out here love to listen to the music, and there are specific things we love but never talked about because we don’t have the language to explain them.
Him pointing out the” call and response between Elliot and Ric”, I know it is there, but hearing him say it that way made it even better to hear.
Boy does Ken Appreciate the Cars. It was like – romantic. Absolutely awesome.
I have always over-reacted to music, it is just part of me, so when I listen to this stuff my heart gets so full.
and my stomach goes into knots (probably not a good thing).
And then of course Bye Bye Love, after hearing the conversation of YAIGT going into hearing BBL.
Holy Crap – I was over the top.
Clouds as a verb – yes I agree goes along with fogging up my energy.
I had to pause at this point because I am too excited and my other life is calling me.
Thanks for doing these things.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yay! I’m so glad you enjoyed it!! ❤ ❤ ❤ And I *totally* get you when you describe your reaction to music. It is the same for me!