The Rat, June 1977: Take Me Now!

Another recording of The Cars at The Rat has surfaced, and it brings with it another rare gem!

I’m just going to jump right to the lightning bolt: they performed “Take Me Now” during the set! As we know, the demo of the song was released on the 1995 Just What I Needed: The Cars Anthology, but I believe this is the first time we’ve heard this beautiful ballad played live. A few unfortunate flaws in the original tape mean that some significant sections of the song were lost, but what a treasure nonetheless, and such a clear recording! Ben’s achy vocal is layered so perfectly over Greg’s gentle keyboards and David’s faithful percussion foundation. Ah, it’s just so gorgeous! Someday… someday, I hope we can hear all of the verses. For now… 

As for the full gig, the band played a total of 9 songs in about half an hour. Here’s the set list:

  • “Leave Or Stay”
  • “Cool Fool”
  • “I Don’t Want To” (Elliot on vocals)
  • “I’m In Touch With Your World”
  • “Take Me Now” (!!)
  • “Come Back Down”
  • “See Through My Eyes”
  • “Looking To See You”
  • “You Can Have ‘Em” (aka “Sleepy Wasted Afternoon”)

Notice anything missing? The absence of “Just What I Needed” is a surprise, and leads me to think that they probably did an encore that either didn’t get caught on the tape or wasn’t released with the digitized files.

A little side note: I’m still digging to pinpoint the date of this performance, and to confirm that it is from The Rat. I’m not sure why, but something about the way the guy introduces the band at the beginning seems a little off and it kind of has me questioning the details. It seems like he’s trying to acquaint the audience with the band, but we know that The Cars had played there a bunch of times by this point. Of course, it’s not like I’ve ever even seen a show at The Rat, so what do I know? I may be totally off base, but those bits of info are puzzle pieces I’d like to have firmly in place. I’ll poke around a little more. 

The show seems to get off to a rocky start. After “Leave Or Stay,” the audience is either not paying attention, or they don’t realize the song is over, because there is an awkward moment of silence before the smattering of applause. Ric seems a little grumpy when he says, “There’s a lot of fucking room up here,” possibly referring to the audience area in front of the stage. Perhaps he got even more irritated by the overly-enthusiastic fan (apparently named Roy?) that causes a ruckus during the first half of the set. Or maybe that was just me getting annoyed. Haha!

Happily, the crowd becomes more enthusiastic as the band proves its mettle. Ric, Ben, and Elliot all take turns singing lead, one right after the other, and the contrast in sound and style is obvious but certainly not unpleasant. At a minimum, it underscores just how much talent these guys had to draw from. 

Benjamin Orr by Robert Post, 1977
Benjamin Orr by Robert Post, 1977

Whether he’s on lead vocals or singing backup, Ben weaves his way through the songs, his voice silky and smooth. He puts a more melodic spin on traditionally snarky songs like “Cool Fool” and “See Through My Eyes” than we find on other recordings (“nothin’s free, honey…” mmm). On “I’m In Touch With Your World,” Ben sings backup with an irrepressible seductive mellowness (at 13:03, for example), and his tranquil delivery of “Come Back Down” is flat out hypnotic. 

And since we’re talking about “Come Back Down,” after you soak up Ben’s vocal, I highly recommend that you listen through the song a second time, and maybe a third! You can really pick up the peppy fills in David’s drumming, Ben’s swaying bass, and all of Elliot’s brilliant guitar flourishes. Oh, and Greg’s perfectly understated keyboard outro that kicks in at 19:30… So, so good!

About Elliot: he is definitely delivering the goods in this show. While I understand the band’s decision not to have him continue as a vocalist, it’s always electrifying when EE takes the mic. He rips through a flaming and growly performance of “I Don’t Want To,” the most rollicking song of the whole show. Even as he continues to be a force on backing vocals, his guitar playing never lags. He stretches out some in “Looking to See You,” then he really lays into the audience with his work on “You Can Have ‘Em.” 

Greg is no slouch, either. His inventiveness and dexterity on “I’m In Touch With Your World” are moving the band closer and closer to their final studio version. “Looking To See You” really showcases his keyboard prowess, and it’s the ultimate cherry on top when he pulls out his sax on “You Can Have ‘Em.” Knowing now that it wouldn’t be long before that instrument would begin gathering dust, I just love when we are treated to him playing it in these early recordings.

All the while, David’s impeccable drumming, steady and stylish, is the essential framework of the whole show. No wonder they are screaming for more at the end! 

BONUS: There’s a good bit of audience and stage chatter, which I love (did you hear Ben saying, “I’ll have that, uh… soda… anytime” at 20:50?) It always adds that real-world touch that makes you feel like you’re at one of the tables in the club. I only wish there was more! It seems like there are a few places between songs where the transition is abrupt and I wonder what’s lost. No reason to dwell on that, though, when there is so much to love about this show.

Here’s the full set — take your time! When you’re done, leave me a comment and tell me your favorite part. Enjoy! ❤ 


Please remember that these live audios are not to be bought or sold!

Be sure to subscribe to my YouTube channel and tap on the little bell to get a notification when I upload something new. Also, I’ve started keeping a playlist of the live shows in chronological order. You can check it out here.

Advertisement

8 thoughts on “The Rat, June 1977: Take Me Now!

  1. I loved Take Me Now! Ben’s voice sounded awesome! I had never heard that song before. And I love when Ric said “I’m in touch with your world, among other things.” Lol. And loved the part when you could hear Ben sweetly ask for a soda. And Greg’s keyboards on that one song were fantastic! Elliot and David were great as usual too.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Terrific set! Once again a single unwavering truth is confirmed: Benjamin Orr’s voice and presence could have led any band playing any type of music to superstardom, and Ric was damn fortunate that Ben chose his wagon to hitch himself to. Yes, they greatly benefited from their long partnership, but Ric won that deal. Also, I still don’t exactly understand what Come Back Down is about, but my goodness I would not keep him waiting and wondering long!! lol Thanks for sharing this and Happy New Year!

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Thank you so much for ” Take Me Now “. My first time hearing this song. Just when I think I’ve heard all their songs you pull out another one!😊 It gives me that same romantic feel of Indigo. It’s no wonder we fall in love with him. Ric had a vision when he first heard Ben sing. Good fortune for us, huh?

    Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s